Sunday, 15 November 2026

Doom Painting and the Uprising offer insights on the 1381 Peasants Revolt with lessons for today

There have been two recent works marking the Peasants Revolt of 1381. An excellent book, Doom Painting, by A.K Blakemore and a Paul Greengrass film, the Uprising, starring Andrew Garfield as the ploughman. Unsurprisingly, the book is the more detailed and accurate account, though both genre have their value. The book, particularly, draws parallels with the situation today. England of the 14th century has just suffered a plague, that has wiped out a third of the population. The mass of working people are yoked to the land, exploited by the ruling class of the time. Heavily taxed and abused, with huge levels of inequality. The people have had enough, with a revolt starting in Brentwood, Essex. The leader, Wat Tyler, virtually falls into the role, making a couple of speeches that hit the spot, stirring the masses. The revolt spreads across the river into Kent, then out across the country. The rebels, eventually, march on London. Blakemore traces the development of the revolt over 15 days in June - Corpus Christi. One of the great strengths of the book is how it gets to grips with the detailed reality of every day life for working people. The struggle just to survive, then the feeling of liberation as they collectively begin to believe that things can be different. Blakemore builds the characters well. Tyler has fought for the Crown in France, so is well equipped for combat.The priest, John Ball provides passion, intellect and some strategic advice. Then, there is the shady character, Thomas Raven, who Tyler never really trusts and seems to have other dark agendas. One of the ways in which the film differs is that the story is told from the viewpoint of a mythical character - the Ploughman, rather than Tyler. His depiction emphasises the agricultural element, with his chosen weapon always being the synth. Tyler is another character in the film. The revolt gathers pace, with enemies of the people being slain, whilst tax records are destroyed during the progression. The achilles heal of the revolt is a belief in the monarch, Richard II. The cry of the rebels is to be for King Richard and the True Commons. So the King is seen as sullied by his nobles and barons, rather than the head of the structure of oppression of the people. The 14-year old king sees potential here to use the revolt to rid himself of some of those around him, whilst ingratiating himself to the masses. This intriguing situation is played upon in both accounts. At the time, infant king, Richard II, is dominated by his council, and particularly his uncle John of Gaunt, who is away with the army, fighting in Scotland at this time. There is much violence in the book and film. Beheadings of a gruesome nature, such as when Tyler takes eight blows to behead the Archbishop of Canterbury and former Chancellor, Simon Sudbury, at the Tower. The film also has numerous beheadings, with the King, losing many of his less popular courtiers in the process. In the end, ofcourse, the monarch triumphs, dumping the rebels and exacting bloody revenge. Both book and film have deficiencies in terms of this conclusion of the story. The long book - 663 pages- graphically describes events over the two weeks in June but then there seems to be a rushed finish. The rebels appear in total charge, having taken over London - including the Tower. There have been the executions of Sudbury and others. The Royals are holed up in one of their properties. Yet, Tyler rides out to meet the King alone, only to be slaughtered by Mayor of London, William Walworth, and his entourage. The film illustrates this moment more graphically, as the Mayor's men step out from behind the trees, showering the rebels with arrows. The end of the film is more bizarre, having followed the historic record, quite closely, a flight of fancy then ensues, as the ploughman turns into Robin Hood, who exacts revenge on the King and Walworth a year after the great betrayal. Both book and film though offer an interesting insight into this period of history. Blakemore slides in references to the present day, such as that one per cent of the population still own a third of the land - most drawn from the Royals and aristocracy. Also, a thread from the sacking of the Savoy Palace (John of Gaunt's property), whereby the riches removed, enabled the future generations of a family to socially progress through the classes The historic lesson ofcourse is never to trust the Royals and the ruling class. Another revolt, the Pilgrimage of Grace in the 16th century was put down by Henry VIII - showing similar duplicity and ruthlessness. It was not until the civil war that the monarchy was finally removed (decapitated). Then, Cromwell moved against the more progressive elements, such as the Levellers. They had been making similar demands to those who took part in the Peasant Revolt three centuries earlier. The monarchy returned and survived, adapting, yet, remaining at the head of the yoke of repression. The Doom Painting and Uprising offer excellent insights on this period of rebellion. The book particularly looks to the present day, widespread dissatisfaction with the rulers, amid harsher conditions of life. Another rebellion in the offing but will the naive belief in the most powerful to come through for the true commons triumph again?

An apology for the slave trade is not enough?

There has been much talk about whether Britain should apologise for its role in the slave trade and pay reparations. The present mood music seems to be it may do the former but not the latter. Then the question would be what is the value of an apology, without something substantive to back it up - it seems hollow and meaningless? But what of the case for apology and acknowledgement of what has occurred. Historian Professor David Olusuga''s recent two part documentary, Finding Britain's Slave Traders, laid out how the trade developed. The early British involvement came in Elizabeth I's reign - indeed she underwrote some of the largest ventures. This foray, though, ended, following an altercation with the Spanish. The trade, then, really picked up under the Stuarts. James, Duke of York, (later James II) headed the Royal Africa Company (RAC). This brutal body, in some ways equivalent to the East India Company, dominated the trade. Indeed, there was a period when the private companies trying to break into the trade, were being attacked, imprisoned and tortured by the RAC. The RAC, though, faded with the demise of James and accession of William and Mary. The private sector then came into its own, increasing and dominating the trade. The huge wealth built on the back of the slave trade created some incredibly rich people. Initially, the trade centred on London but later extended to Bristol and Liverpool. It can be argued that proceeds from the trade built these places into the major cities they are today. Those who made such wealth from the trade needed somewhere to put their money. This turned out to be the embryonic industries of the industrial revolution. So, it can be argued, slave money helped fund the growth of Britain as a major capitalist power. Though, Britain had a big role in the slave trade, it was one of the first countries to turn abolitionist in 1807. After, that date the Royal Navy was tasked with fighting the trade - a real case of poacher turned gamekeeper. This valiant role though should not be discarded in weighing up the culpability of Britain for the slave trade. Individual traders ofcourse turned to other means, such as indentured labour, but slavery on the face of it was outlawed. It is these individuals that Olusuga highlights, when he picks up on the work of the research team at Lancaster University team that has created the Register of British Slave Traders The register comprises details of 13,000 slave owners. It was these people that the British government, back in the nineteenth century, decided should be compensated not the slaves. These payments were only completed in 2015. So over the centuries there has never been a problem with compensating the perpetrators, only the victims. As more evidence has come to light of the slave trade, so the call for action has grown ever louder. There was the pulling down of the statues of trader Edward Colson and others a few years ago A number of public institutions, such as the Church of England, are looking to reconcile and compensate in some way for their past actions. Some education, arts and financial bodies are looking to do similar things. These moves are all welcome but the British state, going right back to Elizabeth I and James II, has played a central role in this trade. An apology is the minimum required, with reperations of some kind needed to make that action meaningful. Real action is needed. It is no good viewing history totally as a static academic record of the past - interesting but essentially a stage, easily put aside. The people and institutions that dominate today often do so due to the proceeds that came somewhere down the line from the slave trade. The British empire and industrial base was partly built on this trade. This atrocity needs to be addressed. The cries of it's nothing to do with us today really won't wash when the history is properly examined. One thing taught by history is that the failure to learn the lessons ensure that the mistakes of the past are repeated. Maybe the continued existence of slavery and trafficking today is proof of that mantra? So to move forward, there needs to be a proper peace and reconciliation process relating to the the past crimes of the slave trade. This will need acknowledgement, contrition and reperation for those effected. Anything less will be a great betrayal of those past generations. 'Finding Britain's Slave Traders' is available on BBC i-player

Thursday, 22 October 2026

BBC drama, Time, exposes moribund nature of prison system but to the public want to hear?

The brilliant drama Time about a young persons detention centre raises questions about incarceration and the criminal justice system. Written by Jimmy McGovern, starring David Tennant and Siobhan Finneran, Time brings home the violence and terror of prison.The understaffing, means the prisoners end up locked in cells for 23 hours a day. This exasperates many already underlying problems. Efforts to rehabilitate, such as literacy provision go by the way side. The staff are on the edge, becoming more violent themselves This is the third series of Time, the first focusing on adult male prison, the second adult female prison and now the youngsters.This final series is possibly the most hard hitting. It is often a difficult watch but fantastic drama, with McGovern's brilliant writing highlighting an important contemporary issue. Finneran's character, chaplain, Sister sounds Marie Louise, is the only one to appear in all three series. She offers a beacon of hope for the prisoners. In this final series, she has lost her faith after an affair with a Catholic priest. The affair is ended, after pressure from the hierarchy. She suggests the head chaplain may not want her now she has lost her faith. But he responds saying she is needed now more than ever. Tennant puts in a great performance as Bobby Bailey, tortured at work, whilst his private life is also in turmoil. He faces the dilemma of doing the right moral thing in telling the truth or colluding in a cover up for a colleague. The moment on the second episode, where stretched to the limit, Bailey is left to look after a whole wing because his fellow officer has pulled a sickie, is particularly powerful. The icing on the cake comes when he confronts Freddie Jennings (Daniel Ryan). at the golf course, rather than on his sick bed. Jennings is another torn individual, with some good intentions but overcome in the end by the need for self preservation. There are several excellent performances from those playing the young offenders. Chukwubuikem Molokwu as murdered inmate Christopher/Ushindi and Ollie McNulty, as Peter, a conscience stricken member of a murder gang, are particularly outstanding in their TV acting debuts. Again, potentially decent people if given the chance to show it. That opportunity is only occasionally seen, then snatched away, as most become overcome by the need to survive in what amounts to a jungle with few rules. The moral dilemmas mount up, with some redemption found in the end. The concern, though, is that despite such drama and other documentaries, the public understanding of crime and punishment seems to have changed little. The populist belief seems to be that offenders should be locked away for as long as possible - out of sight, out of mind. Note, the frankly ludicrous outcry over the recent decision to release some prisoners early to make space in the prisons for more inmates. The early releases will have made little difference to the offenders concerned. The point missed amid the public clamour to keep people locked up is that the system does not work. The individuals will reoffend because that is what prisoners are bound to do if they are not rehabilitated. Some 30 to 40 per cent of offenders reoffend on release. Prison does not work, it simply makes individuals into better criminals on release. As a former Chief Inspector of Prisons noted sooner or later all but a handful of prisoners will be released and each could be living next door to you or me. It is in everybody's interest to rehabilitate prisoners. But this is not happening. There have been efforts made to cut incarceration by the present government and the previous David Cameron Conservative administration but both have been confounded by media led public outcry. The latest being the reaction to the early release program. The stock response then from the politicians is to promise to build more prisons and incarcerate more people. The countries that incarcerate fewer people, using other methods to punish and rehabilitate in the community are doing better in addressing offending. The present situation, as exposed in Time needs addressing. Building more prisons, locking up more people for longer is no solution. Community based sentences, restorative justice, rehabilitation, valued staff and efforts to address the root causes of what drives crime in the first place are what is needed. There will be mistakes and problems along the way but in the end society will be served much better, than by the present approach of simply warehousing people in increasingly dangerous and volatile institutions. All this leads to, eventually, are prison riots, prisoner suicides and better equipped prisoners being released to commit more crime on the streets. Time to think again and seek a little redemption.

Wednesday, 7 October 2026

Excellengt analysis for Gordon Brown of the state we're in and ways out

The Future Starts with us by Gordon Brown Published by Simon & Schuster, £25 Former Prime Minister and Chancellor Gordon Brown has delivered a most timely analysis of the chaotic state of the world, with some rays of hope for the future. Brown does an excellent critique of the economic system, the ravages caused by neoliberalism, the eclipse of concepts like the common good and rise of nationalism. The central narrative is one of economic decline across the world, alongside a hollowing out, if not eradication, of civil society. This has in turn led to the rise of populist nationalism across the world. Brown champions the idea of an active, rather than a passive, social citizenry. He identifies trade unions, faith groups, political parties, as all being amongst those in decline. There are some alarming studies, such as one recalling war games based on AI control of nuclear deterrents. This found that in 21 simulated crises, AI chose to use nuclear weapons 95% of the time. The book ofcourse was completed before the more recent alarms being sounded about AI destroying humanity in 10 years. Brown critiques neoliberalism, as having been responsible for many of the problems today - including the rise of nationalist populism. He doesn't, however, admit to his own role as a major player on that scene from 1997 to 2010. Indeed, his references to his own service during this time are very little. He admits ringing Turkish despot Recep Tayyip Erdogan, in 2008, supporting his efforts to get his country into the EU. Something blocked by France and Germany. The Sure Start program also gets a passing mention as a plus in community building. But that is about it. This approach adds a certain air of objectivity, though some may also see it as a falseness. The Left will also be irritated by the effective airbrushing of the Corbyn years. Talking of the demise of political parties, as mass member bodies, there is no reference as to how the Labour Party was the biggest party in Europe, with more than half a million members, under Corbyn. Indeed, many of the ideas of the Corbyn period could be argued to be what Brown would now like to see as part of the way forward - economically and community wise. The Andy Burnham mantra, obviously, resonates with much of what Brown is suggesting, with a new world order, the revival of civic life and active citizenry. Brown describes a world of multipolar as opposed to unipolar power. So, there will be America and China but if the other countries pull together into a co-operative block they can be at least, if not more, influential. The narrative in this respect is very much in line with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney's prognosis for the future. On solutions, Brown has some interesting ideas for co-operation between countries on issues like climate change, poverty and economic development. Central to success though is equality, empathy and co-operation. Civil society needs to be rebuilt and supported, alongside international economic fairness. At times the book gets bogged down in stats and can seem rather turgid. But overall, it is an excellent analysis of what has gone wrong and what can be done to put it right. Brown seems to have much faith in technology. He does identify some of the corrosive effects of social media and the like. He, for instance, highlights growing isolation and loneliness in society. However, he doesn't really identify how - in detail - this atomisation can be addressed. It is, afterall, a feature of the present economic model that needs to change. Brown certainly wants change. He wants community rebuilt, so a feeling that all belong. A very good read, particularly apposite at the moment, with some of the ideas being proposed by Burnham's Labour government.

Friday, 25 September 2026

Spectacular production of Golden Boy at the Almeida

Golden Boy Almeida Theatre Josh O'Connor puts in a towering performance as Joe Bonaparte in this latest revival of the 1937 play about the American dream. Written by Cliff Odets during the depression years, the play focuses on a character torn between his passion and talent for the violin and prize fighting. His father, Mr Bonaparte (Stanley Townsend) wants his son to pursue music but once Joe gets caught up with boxing manager Tom Moody (Daniel Mays) he sees a way to attain wealth and fame. Joe rejects the violin getting more focused and violent in the ring. All ofcourse ends in tragedy but there are fascinating twists and turns along the way. The torn character of Lorna Moon (Hayley Squires), girlfriend of Moody but in love with Joe. Mr Bonaparte heartbroken at his son's rejection of the violin but never giving up on him Nor, his brother, union activist, Frank (Richard Fleeshman). Boxing is never an easy sport to depict in a dramatic context, and this Almeida production is no exception. Fight scenes centre around a large punch bag centre stage, with videos screened on the back walls. Never totally convincing. Bonaparte's opponents trot on and off. That said O'Connor does a great job of bringing out the physicality of the fight scene. He wrestles with the punch bag - the ongoing physical damage on his body reminiscent of Robert De Niro as Jake LaMotta in the film Raging Bull. The young Joe is played by Oscar Prout, who appears, almost ghost like in many scenes. The often sleazy fight scene is well depicted with a lot of high octane masculinity on show, from managers, fighters and gangsters. The character of gangster, Eddie Fuseli, is well played by Zubin Carla - a role that could easily tip over into farce. The slightly cramped set is well used, moving between house, manager's office and fights. The trademark crucifix of the Italian family on the wall. The music ensemble are situated at the back of the stage - in what at times can appear like a cupboard. This is opened and shut by different characters. The effect being to help illustrate the passing nature of music in Joe's life. Symbolically, at one point, young Joe gets chased up into the musicians section. There are a number of excellent performances, such as Mays as Moody, Squires as Moon but it is O'Connor as Joe, who holds it all together with a strong physical and emotional performance. The play is well directed by Sam Yates, ensuring plot lines are clear amid what could become confusing in the space. The return of Golden Boy to the stage is timely, with the world today increasingly coming to resemble much of what occurred in the 1930s. Odets himself was rather drawn between his passion for social justice and material well being. Briefly, a communist, he supported many left wing causes. Odets reputation, though, suffered, after his 1952 appearance at Senator Joseph McCarthy's House Committee on Un-American activities. This Sam Yates version of Golden Boy is most welcome at this time of tumult in an uncertain world. It also underlines the futility if the American dream! Runs till 31 October

Triple lock debate should not ignite intergenerational conflict - the issue is levelling up and inroduction of Universal Basic Income

The debate about whether the triple lock on pensions can be afforded has once again stirred amid budget speculation. Predictably, the mainstream media sets the debate in terms of intergenerational conflict, namely the elderly have it all, whilst younger generations are denied. So, let's impoverish the elderly. The fifth richest economy in the world cannot afford a decent pension (the one we have compares unfavourably with other European and Scandinavian countries). The whole debate is a false construct. The pension is affordable - the National Insurance fund has been billions in credit for years. It only reduced when the last Tory government made crazy cuts to National Insurance contributions. What is more life expectancy is no longer rising - there are also huge disparities in life expectancy depending on where you live and the circumstances. Population worldwide is in decline. The state pension is a right, not a welfare benefit or a privilege. People have paid 35 years plus to earn that pension. There is also little mention made of benefits, like the billions saved in free care provided by grandparents for their children and grandchildren, the voluntary work undertaken and increasing numbers of the elderly who continue to work. On the wider issues, there is AI - if it does wipe us all out the whole argument is a bit academic. If many jobs become redundant, the question will be what happens to the people? How will they earn a living? The obvious answer in a Universal Basic Income, levelling things up for young and old. This is where the debate should be not on trying to impoverish the elderly and drive a wedge between young and old on pensions. The final point is that any politician who attacks pensions and pensioners benefits is very unwise. Remember the winter fuel allowance debacle. The bottom line is that pensioners register highest amongst the cohort of citizens who vote. Alienate them at your electoral peril. published on Labour List - 21/10/2026

Sunday, 20 September 2026

Intriguing tale of resentment and revenge

Wasp, Wanstead Fringe An intriguing tale of abuse, bullying, revenge and long held grudges unveils in this two handed Morgan Lloyd Malcolm play. The Wasp twists through a number of scenarios, centering on two former school mates, meeting up after 20 years. One, Heather (Chloe Orrock) initially appears settled in a middle class lifestyle, married, with a career. The layers of insecurity, though, driving vengeance, quickly peel back. The other, Carla (Kylie Ann Ford), is having a far rougher ride in life, pregnant, working as a prostitute. She, though, is the cause of many of Heathers problems, though, it is not a one way street. But the tables turn and turn again, with scars from the past brought up to devastating effect on both protagonists. An indecent proposal sits at the centre of the plot. This East London Theatre production sees the play presented in the round. This provides an intimacy to the two handed production, bringing the audience into the action. Orrock and Ann Ford do well in holding the attention for the whole 90 minute duration of what is a challenging play. Though the first half zips along, a little of the momentum is lost in the second half. The Lloyd Malcolm play though is intriguing, moving from one scenario to another before the explosive conclusion. This Wanstead Fringe production is well directed by Jon Fentiman, using the small space well, with a simple set. The confined nature of the setting also demands much of the two performers, who rise to the challenge. An excellent tale, well worth seeing. On at the Wanstead Curtain from 23 to 26 September - Wansteadfringe.org / Eastlondontheatre.org.uk